Table C1-1: Boiler NOx Control Cost Effectiveness Summary
Boiler Capacity |
Hours of Operation |
Heat Release |
Reduction (ton/yr) |
LNB/FGR/SCR Cost |
Cost Effectiveness |
(MMBtu/hr) |
(hr/yr) |
(MMBtu/yr) |
HR * (0.14-0.0107) |
Total Annualized ($/yr) |
($/ton) |
50 |
8760 |
438000 |
28.3167 |
$186,359 |
$6,581 |
50 |
6570 |
328500 |
21.237525 |
$169,837 |
$7,997 |
50 |
4380 |
219000 |
14.15835 |
$153,315 |
$10,829 |
50 |
2454 |
122700 |
7.932555 |
$138,784 |
$17,495 |
50 |
2190 |
109500 |
7.079175 |
$140,385 |
$19,831 |
50 |
876 |
43800 |
2.83167 |
$127,238 |
$44,934 |
70 |
8760 |
613200 |
39.64338 |
$219,938 |
$5,548 |
70 |
6570 |
459900 |
29.732535 |
$196,986 |
$6,625 |
70 |
4380 |
306600 |
19.82169 |
$174,034 |
$8,780 |
70 |
2190 |
153300 |
9.910845 |
$151,083 |
$15,244 |
70 |
1865 |
130550 |
8.4400575 |
$147,677 |
$17,497 |
70 |
876 |
61320 |
3.964338 |
$137,312 |
$34,637 |
80 |
8760 |
700800 |
45.30672 |
$235,108 |
$5,189 |
80 |
6570 |
525600 |
33.98004 |
$211,187 |
$6,215 |
80 |
4380 |
350400 |
22.65336 |
$187,267 |
$8,267 |
80 |
2190 |
175200 |
11.32668 |
$163,346 |
$14,421 |
80 |
1752 |
140160 |
9.061344 |
$158,562 |
$17,499 |
80 |
876 |
70080 |
4.530672 |
$148,993 |
$32,885 |
100 |
8760 |
876000 |
56.6334 |
$250,573 |
$4,424 |
100 |
6570 |
657000 |
42.47505 |
$225,566 |
$5,311 |
100 |
4380 |
438000 |
28.3167 |
$200,558 |
$7,083 |
100 |
2190 |
219000 |
14.15835 |
$175,551 |
$12,399 |
100 |
1480 |
148000 |
9.5682 |
$167,443 |
$17,500 |
100 |
876 |
87600 |
5.66334 |
$160,546 |
$28,348 |
130 |
8760 |
1138800 |
73.62342 |
$297,078 |
$4,035 |
130 |
6570 |
854100 |
55.217565 |
$265,523 |
$4,809 |
130 |
4380 |
569400 |
36.81171 |
$233,969 |
$6,356 |
130 |
2190 |
284700 |
18.405855 |
$202,414 |
$10,997 |
130 |
1288 |
167440 |
10.824996 |
$189,418 |
$17,498 |
130 |
876 |
113880 |
7.362342 |
$183,482 |
$24,922 |
150 |
8760 |
1314000 |
84.9501 |
$316,647 |
$3,727 |
150 |
6570 |
985500 |
63.712575 |
$283,108 |
$4,444 |
150 |
4380 |
657000 |
42.47505 |
$249,569 |
$5,876 |
150 |
2190 |
328500 |
21.237525 |
$216,029 |
$10,172 |
150 |
1182 |
177300 |
11.462445 |
$200,592 |
$17,500 |
150 |
876 |
131400 |
8.49501 |
$195,906 |
$23,061 |
175 |
8760 |
1533000 |
99.10845 |
$372,937 |
$3,763 |
175 |
6570 |
1149750 |
74.3313375 |
$328,429 |
$4,418 |
175 |
4380 |
766500 |
49.554225 |
$284,383 |
$5,739 |
175 |
2190 |
383250 |
24.7771125 |
$240,337 |
$9,700 |
175 |
1104 |
193200 |
12.49038 |
$218,495 |
$17,493 |
175 |
876 |
153300 |
9.910845 |
$213,909 |
$21,583 |
200 |
8760 |
1752000 |
113.2668 |
$422,048 |
$3,726 |
200 |
6570 |
1314000 |
84.9501 |
$371,041 |
$4,368 |
200 |
4380 |
876000 |
56.6334 |
$320,035 |
$5,651 |
200 |
2190 |
438000 |
28.3167 |
$269,028 |
$9,501 |
200 |
1074 |
214800 |
13.88682 |
$243,036 |
$17,501 |
200 |
876 |
175200 |
11.32668 |
$238,425 |
$21,050 |
230 |
8760 |
2014800 |
130.25682 |
$466,090 |
$3,578 |
230 |
6570 |
1511100 |
97.692615 |
$407,638 |
$4,173 |
230 |
4380 |
1007400 |
65.12841 |
$349,147 |
$5,361 |
230 |
2190 |
503700 |
32.564205 |
$290,735 |
$8,928 |
230 |
995 |
228850 |
14.7951525 |
$258,841 |
$17,495 |
230 |
876 |
201480 |
13.025682 |
$255,665 |
$19,628 |
250 |
8760 |
2190000 |
141.5835 |
$486,814 |
$3,438 |
250 |
6570 |
1642500 |
106.187625 |
$426,424 |
$4,016 |
250 |
4380 |
1095000 |
70.79175 |
$366,035 |
$5,171 |
250 |
2190 |
547500 |
35.395875 |
$305,645 |
$8,635 |
250 |
961 |
240250 |
15.5321625 |
$271,755 |
$17,496 |
250 |
876 |
219000 |
14.15835 |
$269,411 |
$19,028 |